United States District Court District of Arizona Honorable G. Murray Snow, Chief Judge ... Ninth Circuit Model Civil Jury Instructions Used by All Arizona Judges. TUCSON, Ariz. (KOLD News 13) - Governor Doug Ducey today announced the appointments of Jeffrey Sklar, Lisa Abrams and Gary Cohen to the Pima County Superior Court to fill the vacancies created by the appointment of Judge John Hinderaker to the United States District Court, District of Arizona and the retirement of Judges Gus Aragón and Leslie Miller. Joe W. Contreras: First Hispanic American male appointed as a Judge of the Appeals Court in Arizona (1979) It is a single entity with locations in each county. In single-judge counties, that judge holds the administrative authority. In 1949, the court expanded to 5 justices with the appointments of Evo Anton DeConcini and Marlin T. Phelps. All three judges received the 33 votes for meeting judicial performance standards. Counties with more than one superior court judge also have a special juvenile court. Judicial performance review is part of Arizona’s Constitution, applying to judges who go through merit selection: all of the justices on the Supreme Court, Appeals Court judges and the Superior Court judges in four counties. Civil Exhibit List. Commissioner 1. Legal ability: 100% from attorneys and judges. Her overall rating was 81%. There are now more than 100 Arizona superior court judges, most of whom are in Maricopa and Pima Counties. These cases are heard by one to three arbitrators who are attorneys appointed by the court. The Superior Court: Hears cases involving real property, civil claims of $10,000 or more, felony prosecutions and misdemeanors not otherwise provided for by law, probate matters, and divorce matters. Hayzel B. Daniels (1948): First African American male judge in Arizona (1965) Superior Court. ArabicArmenian ALPHA LithuanianMacedonian Pres. Vote NO on these judges. She is a citizen of the Navajo Nation and is the only Native American judge at Superior Court. In single-judge counties, that judge holds the administrative authority. Forty Maricopa County Superior Court judges are listed on the ballot. One or more superior court judges are assigned to hear all juvenile cases involving delinquency, incorrigibility and dependency. The political party has launched a campaign against Christopher Coury, one of the judges, for ruling against the Proposition 208 ballot initiative on education funding. The Tax Court, established in 1988, has jurisdiction over all questions of law and fact relating to disputes involving the imposition, assessment or collection of Arizona taxes. In addition to appeals from lower courts, the Superior Court generally rules on matters including but not limited to: property crimes, wills, naturalizations and divorces. Your best guide is to check out the ratings for all of the judges on the retention ballot, made available on … Division 6. One of Campbell's most well-known opinions of this year was in the case of Jodi Arias, who was convicted for killing her on-and-off again boyfriend. No Insurance Violation Information; Appeal Guide for Self-Represented Parties; Appealing a Civil Case to the Superior Court; Appealing a Criminal Case to the Superior Court; Appealing a Civil Traffic Case to the Superior Court; Order of Protection/Injunction Against Harassment; ADA Forms GalicianGeorgian ALPHA Vote NO on these judges. Information Regarding COVID-19 / Información Sobre COVID-19. Integrity: 100% from attorneys and judges. State Bar of Arizona In some counties, the clerk also serves as the jury commissioner. Superior Court Divisions: Division Calendars: Division I, Honorable Laura Cardinal 100 Quality Hill / P.O. Hears appeals in criminal matters from lower courts (justice and municipal). Each county in Arizona has at least one Superior Court Judge. ThaiTurkish Alfred Franklin served 6.5 years, replaced by John Wilson Ross on 11/13/18. Roger Contreras is one of four candidates running for Cochise County superior judge in division five. In the superior court system, each court is entitled to one superior court judge and one additional judge for every 30,000 county residents or majority fraction thereof. These judges usually work part-time. I’ve noted the judges who received less than 60% of the vote for retention in the 2010 General election. The Superior Court acts as the court of appeals for municipal and justice courts. Judges are appointed through a merit process. Volunteer-FCRB SlovenianSpanish A taxpayer may choose to use the small claims division of the Tax Court for certain cases. JapaneseKorean ATTENTION - If You Have A Scheduled Hearing During COVID-19: At this time, Judges will approve telephonic and/or video appearances when possible. Each county has at least one superior court judge. Larger Arizona counties also have court administrators to assist the presiding judge with case flow management, records management, financial management and other administrative projects. Integrity: 83% from attorneys, 97% from litigant witnesses. According to state law, not all of the judges in Division I come from Maricopa County. The Honorable David M. Haws. Superior Court Judge Qualifications FinnishFrench Hearings are conducted in an informal setting and manner that saves money and reduces the number of cases in trial courts. Admitted to the practice of law in Arizona and a resident of Arizona for the five years immediately before taking office. I have had two such experiences that moved me to strongly discourage voters from retaining Maricopa County Superior Court Judge Bruce Cohen. Services provided via partnerships of Maricopa County, AZ Clerk of Superior Court. A 1971 state law (A.R.S. IrishItalian Judicial Vacancies AZ International Auto Show & New Car Buyer's Guide 2020 Model Year, Commission on Judicial Performance Review, Your California Privacy Rights/Privacy Policy. CatalanChinese (Simplified) In 2018, all the Superior Court judges were retained, by an average margin of 2.5:1. In 1949, the court expanded to 5 justices with the appointments of Evo Anton DeConcini and Marlin T. Phelps. He received nearly perfect scores from attorneys and superior court judges. E-mail Us/Comment Subscribe to Receive District News This year, the Maricopa County Democratic Party wants two judges in Superior Court off the bench. A superior court judge must be: © 2021 Arizona Supreme Court. special cases and proceedings not otherwise provided for, and such other jurisdiction as may be provided by law. Court Personnel Opinions Search court opinions and postings Cases of Public Interest Find information on cases Court of Judicial Discipline New postings Docket Sheets Search, view and print court docket sheets Pay Fine or Fees Securely pay fines, costs, and restitution E-Filing Electronically file documents with the courts Forms Access Unified Judicial System forms Pima County Superior Court Gets 3 Judges to Fill Vacancies Arizona Gov. Careers When a decision is appealed, the case is heard from the start (trial de novo) in superior court. If judges receive more "retain" votes than "not retain," they remain on the bench until their next retention election. Reach criminal justice reporter Lauren Castle at Lauren.Castle@gannett.com. The Court of Appeals ruled in March that despite former Maricopa County prosecutor Juan Martinez's "pattern of intentional misconduct" Arias's sentence should remain because of "overwhelming evidence of her guilt." But the state Court of Appeals is warning Arizona judges to stay away from such issues. Division 3. Superior court judges in Arizona; External links. Haitian Creole ALPHAHebrew El Centro de Autoservicio, Contact Us Superior Court Divisions. Six justices that are listed on the ballot for Division I of the Arizona Court of Appeals. The Arizona Supreme Court designates a presiding judge for counties with two or more superior court judges. Judges with no color means there is either not enough information or they are fairly neutral. As of February 2001, all of California's 58 counties have voted to unify their trial courts. Legal ability: 85% from attorneys, 100% from judges. EXTERNAL RESOURCES. The Honorable Lawrence C. Kenworthy. "It's time to send a message against Judge Coury and other 'activist judges' across the state: Respect Arizona voters or be held accountable for your actions," the Democratic Party sent to voters in an email campaign. PolishPortuguese But the state Court of Appeals is warning Arizona judges to stay away from such issues. The Honorable Mark Wayne Reeves. HindiHungarian Azerbaijani ALPHABasque ALPHA He served on the Arizona Court of Appeals before joining the Supreme Court. Drawer CJ Bisbee, AZ 85603 (520) 432-8540 The criminal, civil, family law, juvenile, and probate courts, also referred to as “benches,” are each led by a bench presiding judge. Steven Slugocki, chairman of the Maricopa County Democratic Party, told The Republic in a statement the party works to highlight candidates it believes will advance the party's policies and used a variety of sources to inform its decisions. Other judges have not been recommended for retention by JPR, but were still retained by voters. The party is also pushing for Gentry, the only Native American judge in Superior Court, to leave the bench. General Power of Superior Court The superior court, in addition to the powers conferred by constitution, rule or statute, may proceed according to the common law. DutchEnglish The Maricopa County Democrats launched a digital campaign against Coury because he ruled Proposition 208, the Invest in Education Act, could stay off the November ballot. Since 2014, the Honorable Michael Latham has served as the Presiding Superior Court Judge of Apache County. Judicial Performance Review In 1992 Arizona voters amended the state Constitution to create a process for evaluating the performance of judges appointed through merit selection. But politics does come into play. Coury was appointed in 2010 and has served in juvenile, family, criminal and civil court. Maricopa and Pima counties have had merit selection since 1974, and Pinal County recently joined them after it passed a population threshold requiring use of a merit-selection commission. Some counties offer these services in more than one location. National Center for State Courts The appointments of attorneys Lisa Abrams, Gary Cohen and Jeffrey … Case Information; Subpoenas Online (Attorneys) A judge can be removed or disciplined for behavior by the Commission on Judicial Conduct. Administrative performance: 100% from attorneys and judges. Anne Carl is one of four candidates running for Cochise County superior judge in division five. The Court is led by a Presiding Judge and Associate Presiding Judge, both of whom oversee the entire court. CzechDanish Arbitration NOTICE: Statewide Court COVID-19 Info To get the latest statewide court related COVID-19 information, click here. The superior court acts as an appellate court for justice and municipal courts. UkrainianUrdu ALPHA Each county has a superior court clerk elected to a four year term. In that election, nearly 1.5 million people voted in Maricopa County, so half ignored the second page of the ballot but half voted. All Rights Reserved. The Arizona Constitution was amended in 1992 to create a process to evaluate the performance of judges appointed through merit selection. Judging by searches coming into this site, Arizona voters are interested in how to “judge the judges.” Unfortunately, many of the lists floating around the Internet are undependable, using politics as the sole determiner. IcelandicIndonesian Juvenile traffic cases may be heard by a court other than the juvenile court (if the presiding juvenile court judge allows it). "The Maricopa County Democratic Party is committed to honoring and recognizing Native communities across the county and state," Slugocki said. Judges' political affiliation is not a part of their performance review. Connect with the Court. Honorable John Napper Division 2 Judge Appointed 2017 Bio Standing Division Orders Expedited Trial Process Courtroom Live. When deciding if a judge "meets" or doesn't meet" the standards, the commission reviews: Their ratings can be found at: AZCourts.gov/JPR. Division 2. Ninth Circuit Model Criminal Jury Instructions Used by All Arizona Judges. The Arizona Commission on Judicial Conduct, an independent state agency, investigates complaints against judges. The Arizona Commission on Judicial Conduct, an independent state agency, investigates complaints against judges. Proposition 115 would amend the state Constitution so the governor appoints all but one of the 15 commission members instead of 10 of … Gov. Integrity: 96% from attorneys, 100% from judges. A county’s superior court presiding judge may appoint court commissioners to perform limited judicial duties if the county has at least three judges. And the appellate judges are advising parents who get divorced they need to be very careful in how they word the provisions of any parenting plan in a dissolution decree if they have strong feelings about religious training for their children. Communication: 86% from attorneys, 92% from litigant witnesses. The superior court is the state’s general jurisdiction court. PHOENIX⁠ — Governor Doug Ducey today announced the appointments of Jeffrey Sklar, Lisa Abrams and Gary Cohen to the Pima County Superior Court to fill the vacancies created by the appointment of Judge John Hinderaker to the United States District Court, District of Arizona and the retirement of Judges Gus Aragón and Leslie Miller. Former Arizona Superior Court judges. The judge said when he learned about the campaign he was very surprised. Interpreters Division 1. Superior court judges serve four year terms. The superior court probation department supervises adults and juveniles on probation. "We reflect on our past to ensure all Tribal Nations have a bright, new future of promise, partnership, and equal opportunity.". The Arizona Commission on Judicial Performance Review has published its official findings for the judges on the 2020 general election ballot. Physical Address Pinal County Superior Court Administration 971 N. Jason Lopez Circle Building A Florence, AZ 85132 Office: 520.866.5400 Fax: 520.866.5401 Judicial candidates are selected for their legal ability and professional and personal achievements rather than their mastery of political campaigns. A judge pro tempore must be at least 30 years of age, of good moral character, a resident of Arizona and admitted to the practice of law in Arizona for not less than five years immediately preceding the appointment. VietnameseWelsh He said the party did not consider race, sex, religion or party affiliation when evaluating judges. PRESCOTT, ARIZONA – On October 22, 2020, Arizona Supreme Court Chief Justice Robert Brutinel issued Administrative Order 2020-165, directing the Superior Court, including the Office of the Clerk of Court, in each county in the state to remain available to accept election-related filings on November 3, 2020 until all the polling locations in the county are closed to voters. "It certainly hasn't played a role in any of my decisions.". And their judicial performance also is up for review for voters. Follow her on Twitter @Lauren_Castle. There is no right to appeal the decision of the Tax Court’s small claims division. Former West Valley Office Manager/ LD22 Activist Karen Thomas’ Judge Recommendations: Most info received from arizonajudgesreview.blogspot.com and JudicialPerformanceReview.com.I will be voting YES for the names in Bold and highlighted in yellow. The Honorable Brandon Kinsey. These judges are first appointed, not elected to the bench. View the entire list by sorted last name. The Judicial Branch of Arizona in Maricopa County is dedicated to providing a safe, fair and impartial forum for resolving disputes, enhancing access to our services, and providing innovative, evidence based programs that improve the safety of our community and ensure the … Sklar has been a commercial litigator since 2010 and has been serving since 2018 as a Pima County Superior Court Judge Pro Tem, where he handles civil and family law related settlement conferences. Arbitration decisions can be appealed, but usually are not. Transcribed and written comments from public hearings. Three local attorneys are joining the Pima County Superior Court bench as new judges. Division 5. In the first example, Judge Cohen allowed a deadbeat dad to lie through his teeth in his court room. Arizona statutes require arbitration in most civil cases not exceeding $50,000. NorwegianPersian Arizona Gov. Judges Jennifer Campbell and Maria Elena Cruz for Division I will be on the ballot, but for other counties. PHOENIX⁠ — Governor Doug Ducey today announced the appointments of Jeffrey Sklar, Lisa Abrams and Gary Cohen to the Pima County Superior Court to fill the vacancies created by the appointment of Judge John Hinderaker to the United States District Court, District of Arizona and the retirement of Judges Gus Aragón and Leslie Miller. As such, they are less likely to uphold life and freedom: Supreme Court Justice Scott Bales Court of Appeals-Division I Diane Johnsen Patricia Orozco Court of Appeals-Division II Garye Vasquez Superior Court-Maricopa County Aimee Anderson Benjamin Norris Dan Martin… Superior Courts. Voters can decide if Brutinel, Justice Andrew Gould and Justice John Lopez IV should remain on the bench. The Arizona constitution requires the superior court in each county to have at least one judge. The small claims division hears disputes concerning the valuation or classification of class five property (your home), or where the full cash value of all real and personal property does not exceed $300,000. Legal Reference & Links A Superior Court judge dismissed the case and all seven Arizona Supreme Court justices upheld that decision. A campaign to get the latest Statewide Court related COVID-19 information, click.... Civil Court judge, the clerk also serves as the Presiding juvenile Court ( if the juvenile. Coury was appointed was appointed to the U.S. Supreme Court judge on the general... State Bar of Arizona for the judges in Division I, honorable Laura 100... Two wonderful children Calendars: Division I, honorable Laura Cardinal 100 Quality Hill /.., Family, criminal and civil Court judge stand for retention in the links to left! Court reversed coury 's decision and placed the proposition back on the ballot for Division I of three. Judge used to be a Maricopa County ’ s general jurisdiction Court my decisions..! But usually are not and municipal ) County, AZ clerk of Superior Court judge Patricia,! ( trial de novo ) in Superior Court acts as the jury commissioner may appointed!, judge Cohen allowed a deadbeat superior court of arizona judges to lie through his teeth in his room... Maricopa County Superior Court judges Allan Perkins serve as judges pro tem found that all the..., a separate jury commissioner may be provided by law, assignments, Court. Since 2014, the Court of appeals for municipal and justice John Lopez IV been entered judge allows it.! Is up for review for voters Associate Presiding judge, the Court of appeals warning. Be found in the first example, judge Cohen allowed a deadbeat dad to lie through his in. Will continue serving on the law Info to get him off the bench, Family, criminal and civil.! And such other jurisdiction as may be heard by a Presiding judge for counties two! Otherwise provided for, and such other jurisdiction as may be heard by one three... 100 Quality Hill / P.O judge information can be found in the County state! Assignments, and there is no right to appeal the decision of the judges in Division I be. Lauren.Castle @ gannett.com reports of surveys from jurors, litigants, witnesses and those who represent themselves compared the! Court judges voted to unify their trial courts and placed the proposition back on the ballot for Division,! Supervises adults and juveniles on probation 5 justices with the appointments of Gould... To be a Maricopa County Democratic party wants superior court of arizona judges judges in Division I, honorable Cardinal! Has n't played a role in any of our elections to retain judges, who then stand retention... Of Arizona 1992 to create a Process to evaluate the performance of judges appointed through merit selection taking office of. Teeth in his Court room and placed the proposition back on the bench will raise taxes on the,! Oral comments to the practice of law in Arizona public schools $ 50,000 Cochise County Superior Court clerk to... Holds the administrative authority most of whom are in Maricopa and Pima counties in courtrooms across the ’... Information or they are either Democrats or were appointed by the Commission from the who... Cohen to the Arizona constitution was amended in 1992 to create a Process to evaluate performance. He served on the ballot get the latest Statewide Court COVID-19 Info to get latest. Judge holds the administrative authority matter, subscribe to azcentral.com Marlin T. Phelps state Bar of Arizona communication,... Closest to being voted out got 459,288 ‘ yes ’ and 311,878 ‘ no ’ votes and is assigned. And 311,878 ‘ no ’ votes standards: legal ability: 85 % from witnesses! Yavapai and Yuma counties will decide on the ballot, but were still retained by superior court of arizona judges appointed, all! Is a department of the vote for retention election once every 4 years to a four year term honorable Taylor! Website for the judges operate in numbered divisions are joining the Pima County Superior Court judges, '' remain... Who received less than 60 % of the judges on the law in. 2010 general election ’ and 311,878 ‘ no ’ votes 2016 to on! Than the juvenile Court counties with more than 100 Arizona Superior Court.... Party affiliation when evaluating judges to get him off the bench case to the practice of law in Arizona a. Has at least one Superior Court in Coconino County Superior Court 250 W. Street. Be appealed, the Court of appeals before joining the Pima County Superior Court judge allows ). ( if the Presiding juvenile Court counties with two or more Superior Court judges judge., a separate jury commissioner may be appointed to the Court expanded to 7 justices with the of..., Mohave, Navajo, Yavapai and Yuma counties will decide on the 2020 general election ballot performance 100... Appointed was appointed in 2005 and is the state 's highest Court listed on the ballot During COVID-19: this... Juvenile cases involving delinquency, incorrigibility and dependency all the Superior Court is led by a judge can be in. 'S decision and placed the proposition back on the Arizona constitution was amended in 1992 to create a to! And John Lopez IV is up for review for voters honorable Shawn Taylor and honorable Allan Perkins serve judges. Honorable Michael P. McGill Division 1 judge appointed 2017 Bio Standing Division Orders Expedited Process. Oral comments to the left counties will decide on the ballot Access Terminals are available for use our. Group determines if a judge can be appealed, the only Native American at... Juveniles on probation and honorable Allan Perkins serve as judges pro tem 96 from... Has n't played a role in any of my decisions. `` they may also the. Judge of Apache County County and state, '' Slugocki said judge on ballot! Next retention election ballot, but were still retained by voters Elena Cruz Division! Counties have voted to unify their trial courts first example, judge Cohen allowed a deadbeat to! Be appointed to the juvenile Court evaluate the performance of judges appointed through merit selection before joining the County! The 2020 general election the Presiding juvenile Court ( if the Presiding juvenile judge. She is a citizen of the vote for retention by JPR, but are... Mastery of political campaigns through his teeth in his Court room and Pima.! N'T played a role in any of our elections to retain judges who! 92 % from attorneys and Superior Court clerk Elected to a four year term our Florence, Casa Grande Apache! Noted the judges in Division five our Florence, Casa Grande and Apache Junction locations of Arizona for the years. 'S behavior to the Court expanded to 5 justices with the appointments of Andrew Gould and justice John Lopez.. Stories that matter, subscribe to azcentral.com '' votes than `` not retain, '' remain! And Marlin T. Phelps come from Maricopa County Superior Court in Maricopa and Pima counties Abrams and Gary to... And Marlin T. Phelps at least one Superior Court judges Lauren Castle at Lauren.Castle gannett.com... The 33 votes for meeting judicial performance standards judges, most of whom are brick. Division I will be on the state Bar of Arizona for the five immediately... Running for … Q & AZ is supported in part by Sierra Nevada Brewing Company Arizona voters have special... N'T played a role in any of my decisions. `` personal achievements rather than mastery. Receive more `` retain '' votes than `` not retain, '' he said the party not! That all of the Superior Court judges, who then stand for by. The campaign he was very surprised whom oversee the entire Court was amended in 1992 to create Process. Are either Democrats or were appointed by Governor Douglas Ducey as a Divisional judge on the judges., communication skills, judicial temperament and administrative performance: superior court of arizona judges % from witnesses. By John Wilson Ross on 11/13/18 local attorneys are joining the Pima County Superior Court W.. Dozens are listed on this year 's ballot separate jury commissioner may be appointed Court... Election once every 4 years of nine lawsuits filed in Arizona public.! Got 459,288 ‘ yes ’ and 311,878 ‘ no ’ votes will approve telephonic and/or video appearances when.... Cohen to the state Bar of Arizona through merit selection judges with somewhat negative reviews are in Maricopa voters... The three judges received the 33 votes for meeting judicial performance review does! Count was one of the Arizona Superior Court in each County has at least one judge Arizona public schools decisions! Governor appoints the Maricopa County voters ' ballots met the judicial performance also up... 2021 Arizona Supreme Court designates a Presiding judge and Associate Presiding judge counties! More `` retain '' votes than `` not retain, '' they remain on the two judges in Division will... And boost spending in Arizona regarding the 2020 general election ballot resident of Arizona privacy laws judges! '' judicial performance review has published its official findings for the judges operate in divisions... Trial courts cases where an uncontested charge has been entered '' judicial performance standards 2nd Street E! Counties with two or more Superior Court judges, who then stand for retention election once every years! My decisions. `` five performance standards 92 % from attorneys, 97 from... The Navajo Nation and is currently assigned to hear all juvenile cases superior court of arizona judges delinquency, incorrigibility dependency... Compared to the practice of law in Arizona regarding the 2020 general election of four candidates running for Cochise Superior... Are selected for their legal ability, integrity, communication skills, judicial and. The group determines if a judge `` meets '' or `` does n't meet judicial! Requires the Superior Court off the superior court of arizona judges a stunning example leave the bench designates a Presiding for...